Shastry Virudh Shastry (2023)

Seven-year-old Yaman Shastri has become the apple of his grandparents eyes.

When Yaman’s parents decide to return to America in anticipation of a brave journey, they face staunch opposition from their grandfather.The old man believes that his ancestral home holds the key to the family’s prosperity, and so he starts a family legal battle.

Enthrallingly, the court becomes a stage for magical disputes and heart-touching stories, as Haq’s battle for rights takes an unexpected turn, uncovering the extraordinary bond that binds generations together. Shastri Versus Shastri” weaves a complex web of contemporary dilemmas that strike a chord with urban parents grappling with the complexities of child care.

Set against the picturesque backdrop of Panchgani, the film invites the audience to contemplate the complex threads of family dynamics, especially the delicate balance between generations.

Movie Storyline

At the center of the story is Yaman (played by Kabir Pahwa), a young soul who lives in the embrace of his grandparents, Manohar (played by Paresh Rawal) and Urmila (played by Neena Kulkarni). Panchgani, with its serene landscapes, becomes a sanctuary for Yaman, who thrives in the love and care given by his grandparents.

Meanwhile, his parents, Malhar (played by Shiv Pandit) and Mallika (played by Mimi Chakraborty), are caught up in the demands of their busy careers in Mumbai, bonding with their child through weekend visits and virtual interactions.

The plot takes an interesting turn when Malhar receives a lucrative job offer in the United States, prompting the family to consider an intercontinental move. However, the pleasant peace is disrupted when Manohar Shastri strongly opposes the idea, leading to a tense legal battle over Yaman’s custody.

The film exposes the labyrinth of patriarchal dynamics within families, highlighting the repercussions of generational conflicts. While the story keeps the audience engaged, the final hour introduces a subtle exploration of the consequences of relying on traditional gender roles and familial expectations.

Still, some may argue that the narrative momentum falters during this section, which contains preachy messages that perhaps could have been added more subtly or omitted altogether.

Starcast Performance

“Shastri Viruddh Shastri” not only invites contemplation on the evolving nature of family structures but also challenges the audience to question the societal norms associated with parental responsibilities.

In doing so, it creates a cinematic journey that is both thought-provoking and visually captivating, leaving audiences with a tapestry of emotions and contemplation. Shastri Viruddh Shastri” comes across as a reimagining of the Bengali gem “Posto,” expertly crafted by the same director duo.

A remarkable homage to the original, the film carves out its own niche by incorporating fresh perspectives and nuances into the narrative. Interestingly, veteran Soumitra Chatterjee, who once played the role of Dada in “Posto,” hands over the reins to another veteran actor, Paresh Rawal, in this touching rendition.

The cinematic landscape is painted with a tug of emotions, as “Shastri Versus Shastri” delivers moments that delicately tug at the heartstrings of the audience.

The courtroom confrontation emerges as a powerful tableau, where the son grapples with the pain of his father being constantly interrogated by the lawyer.

Equally compelling is the scene where the child, faced with the insecurities of his collapsing grandfather while returning from school, makes a heartfelt plea for help. These sequences are not simply scripted; they have been carefully crafted to resonate authentically and elicit real emotional responses.

Paresh Rawal, in the role of the kindly grandfather, brings depth to his character by conveying the complexities of his suspicions towards his son driven by his drinking habits and concerns about job instability.

His portrayal is a testament to the actor’s skill, adding layers of authenticity to the family dynamics portrayed on screen. Shiv Pandit and Mimi Chakraborty, playing the roles of Malhar and Mallika, exude confidence, contributing to the overall emotional texture of the film.

Direction and Production

Yet, the spotlight in this compelling social drama belongs to Amrita Subhash, whose portrayal of a sharp and unwavering lawyer leaves an indelible mark. Subhash’s performance is a brilliant one, where every nuance has been carefully crafted, with no room for false notes. Her on-screen presence elevates the legal drama and adds layers of complexity and depth to the unfolding story.

“Shastri Viruddh Shastri” is not just a retelling, but also a reinterpretation that pays homage to its roots while branching out into new territory. With its rich tapestry of performances and emotionally charged moments, the film is a testament to the director duo’s ability to breathe new life into a familiar story, creating an experience that is both nostalgic and refreshingly unique.

“Shastri Viruddh Shastri” skillfully presents the emotional landscape, inviting the audience on a highly relatable journey that will especially strike a chord with urban couples who find echoes of their own lives in its narrative. The film’s charm is further enhanced by its nostalgic embrace of old-world charm carefully woven by the director duo, Nandita Roy and Shiboprasad Mukherjee.

In this cinematic tapestry, the pair creates a canvas that matches the nuances of urban life, offering a mirror to the challenges and intricacies faced by modern couples. The narrative not only captures the essence of familial bonds but also serves as a reflective surface for the audience to see fragments of their experiences reflected on screen.

Yomovies Conclusion

Yet amidst the rich emotional tapestry, consideration must be given to the film’s duration. At a runtime of 140 minutes, “Shastri Versus Shastri” sometimes finds itself skipping through moments that, while contributing to the overall narrative, may test the audience’s patience, especially in the last thirty minutes.

The film’s climax, while emotionally charged, may inadvertently lead viewers to glance at their watches in anticipation, perhaps wishing for a more concise resolution.

Yet, the film’s strength lies in its ability to evoke genuine emotions and connect with the audience on a deeper level. The intricate details of urban life, coupled with the nuanced depiction of family dynamics, ensure that “Shastri Versus Shastri” remains a touching cinematic experience despite the occasional challenges that arise in its time.

It’s a testament to the craftsmanship of the directors in making a film that not only touches the hearts but also leaves room for contemplation long after the credits roll.

Also Read | Mangalavaaram (2023) Movie Review, Direction and Storyline